Orders placed after 3.30pm on 23/08 will be dispatched following the UK Bank Holiday (26/08)
(£)
GBP (Default)
- (€) EUR
People looking for natural ways to support their joint health, skin elasticity, and gut wellness often face a big decision: Should they choose bone broth or collagen supplements?
These options promise similar benefits but work differently in their makeup, preparation, and results. Bone broth has become a popular traditional remedy full of nutrients. Collagen supplements give people a convenient alternative that fits easily into their daily routine.
Joint pain, skin health, and gut function improvements drive many to explore these options. This piece dives into the science behind bone broth and collagen supplements. You’ll learn which option might work best for your needs.
People worldwide have used bone broth as a staple food for thousands of years [1]. This nutrient-rich liquid comes from simmering animal bones and connective tissues with vegetables and herbs.
Making bone broth requires simmering animal bones rich in marrow for a long time. You need these ingredients: Bones (femur and humerus)
The broth needs to simmer between 12 to 24 hours [2] to release vital nutrients from the bones. The acid helps pull out minerals and collagen, which makes the broth more nutritious.
Our bodies contain about 30% collagen as total protein [3]. Here are the main types:
| Type | Source | Primary Benefits |
| Type I | Fish/Bovine | Skin, bones, tendons |
| Type II | Chicken | Joint support |
| Type III | Beef | Cardiovascular health |
| Type V | Eggshells | Cell membrane strength |
Collagen supplements go through hydrolysis to break down proteins into smaller, easier-to-digest peptides [4]. This process helps your body absorb the collagen better.
Key differences of Bone broth vs Collagen in production
The biggest difference lies in how they’re made. Bone broth uses natural extraction through slow cooking, while collagen supplements need industrial processing. The broth contains whole food collagen along with calcium and magnesium [1].
Making collagen supplements involves these steps:
Bone broth keeps its natural form without extra processing and all its nutrients intact. Collagen supplements give you specific types of collagen in measured doses [6].
The nutrient profiles and absorption patterns show clear differences between bone broth and collagen supplements.
A cup of bone broth contains about 39 calories and 9 grammes of protein [7]. The broth’s nutrient content goes beyond protein and includes many beneficial compounds:
Each cup provides 6-12 grammes of collagen protein [10], making it a rich source of this important protein.
Hydrolyzed collagen peptides are the main ingredients in collagen supplements. These broken-down collagen proteins typically contain:
| Component | Amount per Serving |
| Collagen Peptides | 10+ grammes [11] |
| Essential Amino Acids | 19 types [9] |
| Protein | 20g per 22g scoop [7] |
Collagen supplements deliver concentrated amounts of specific collagen types. Types I and III make up over 90% of the body’s collagen [12].
The main difference between these sources lies in how your body absorbs them. Bone broth provides collagen in its whole- food form and includes supporting nutrients that help your body make collagen naturally [10].
Collagen supplements work differently because they go through hydrolysis. This process breaks down long amino acid chains into smaller peptides [13], which results in:
Your body needs vitamin C to absorb and use both forms effectively [14]. Vitamin C works with zinc and copper to help form the triple helix structure that collagen needs [14].
Recent research has shown the unique healing properties of bone broth and collagen supplements. Each offers specific benefits for different health conditions.
Bone broth has powerful anti-inflammatory effects. Studies of ulcerative colitis patients show it reduces inflammatory markers. The research found decreases in IL-1β by 61.12%, IL-6 by 94.70%, and TNF-α by 68.88% [15]. These reductions help boost digestive health and immune function.
Bone broth’s rich nutrient profile provides several benefits:
Clinical studies show that collagen supplements target specific conditions effectively. Research suggests taking 5 grammes of collagen daily for 12 months boosted bone mineral density by up to 7% in postmenopausal women [18].
| Condition | Benefit | Duration |
| Osteoarthritis | Pain relief and improved function | 3-5 months [19] |
| Skin Health | Better hydration and elasticity | 8 weeks [20] |
| Bone Health | Higher bone density | 12 months [18] |
The research depth varies by a lot between these supplements. Collagen supplements have more scientific backing, with decades of clinical trials proving they work [21].
Research highlights show:
Bone broth research is limited, but new studies look promising. Scientists found that chicken-vegetable bone broth’s hyaluronan and chondroitin sulphate helped slow osteoporosis in lab tests [24].
Human studies also show good results. Early research suggests bone broth’s amino acid profile helps improve intestinal health and reduces inflammation [15]. In spite of that, many modern claims about bone broth’s benefits need more scientific proof [24].
Choosing environmentally responsible health supplements needs a good look at both cost and environmental factors. Let’s get into how bone broth and collagen supplements match up in terms of price and their effect on the environment.
Bone broth and collagen supplements’ economic aspects are different based on how they’re made and where they come from. Making bone broth at home is affordable, particularly when you use leftover bones from meals and vegetable scraps [25]. Pre-made bone broth products can be expensive because they take a long time to produce [25].
Location plays a big role in collagen supplement pricing:
These products leave very different environmental footprints. Marine collagen shows promising results for sustainability [3]:
| Source | Environmental Impact | Sustainability Factor |
| Marine Collagen | Lower carbon footprint | Uses fish processing waste |
| Bovine Collagen | Higher resource usage | Requires extensive farming |
Fish processing industries create about 25% waste each year. Bones, skin, scales, and fins make up more than 70% of this waste [3]. This waste ended up providing up to 50% collagen in dry mass, which gives us an eco-friendly option [3].
Quality sourcing is a vital part of both options. Organic certification for bone broth guarantees:
Marine sources are getting more attention in the collagen industry as sustainable options [3]. This transformation addresses several key issues:
State-of-the-art developments in environmentally responsible practises now include sea urchin peristomial membrane and jellyfish as alternative collagen sources [3]. These changes arrange well with European zero-waste strategy to support economic well-being, environmental protection, and social welfare [3].
EU Common Fisheries Policy’s landing obligations created new opportunities for sustainable sourcing. Mediterranean catches include about 18.6% discards that can be employed for collagen production [3].
Your body’s natural collagen production starts declining around age 25 [5]. This timeline helps you choose the right supplementation approach through different life stages.
Each age group has unique collagen needs due to natural decline. Collagen levels reach their peak in the early twenties. People lose about 1% of their collagen every year by age 40 [5]. You need a systematic approach to supplementation based on your age:
| Age Group | Primary Need | Recommended Form |
| 20-30 years | Prevention | Light supplementation |
| 30-50 years | Maintenance | Regular supplementation |
| 50+ years | Restoration | Enhanced supplementation |
Several external factors can affect your collagen levels. These factors speed up collagen breakdown: UV radiation exposure
Research shows different dosage needs across age groups. Adults under 50 can take 2.5-5 grammes of collagen peptides daily to support skin health and joint function [28]. Older adults often need higher doses:
Bone broth guidelines change with age too. Adults can safely drink 175-350ml of bone broth daily [29]. Each cup of bone broth provides 6-12 grammes of collagen [30]. Regular intake gives you the best results.
Some life stages need special attention. Women going through menopause lose up to 30% of their skin’s collagen within five years [31]. They might need more supplements or regular bone broth consumption during this time.
People over 60 show the most obvious signs of collagen depletion [32]. Using both supplements and bone broth together works well for this age group. This approach provides targeted collagen supplementation plus bone broth’s extra nutritional benefits.
Getting the most out of bone broth and collagen supplements depends on when you take them and how you store them. Note that these supplements work best when you take them at specific times during the day.
The best way to start with bone broth is to drink it first thing in the morning. This helps kickstart your digestive system [6]. Here’s a daily guide to help you:
| Time of Day | Recommended Serving | Purpose |
| Morning | 1 cup | Digestive support |
| Between Meals | 1 cup | Appetite control |
| Post-workout | 1 cup | Recovery support |
| Evening | 1 cup | Sleep support |
Regular intake matters more than perfect timing. You should take bone broth daily or at least three times weekly to see results [1].
The right timing and combination of bone broth and collagen supplements will give better results. Here’s what works best: Take collagen supplements on an empty stomach to absorb more [33]
You might need more bone broth if you want to build muscle or reduce joint pain [1].
Good storage will affect how well these supplements work and how long they last. Bone broth stays good in the fridge for up to three days [35]. You can store it longer these ways:
1) Freezing
2) Room Temperature Storage
Collagen supplements usually last one to two years with proper storage [38]. Temperature control is key for bone broth storage. Freezing broth in cubes makes it easy to use just what you need [39].
Storage conditions determine how long collagen powder lasts. An airtight container in a cool, dry spot away from heat and moisture works best [37]. Watch for changes in smell, texture, or colour – these mean it’s time to replace your supplements [40].
| Comparison Aspect | Bone Broth | Collagen Supplements |
| How It’s Made | Natural simmering of bones with vegetables and acids takes 12-24 hours | Industrial processing includes demineralisation, extraction, enzymatic hydrolysis, and sterilisation |
| Protein Content | 9g protein per cup, 6-12g collagen protein | 20g protein per 22g scoop, 10+ grammes collagen peptides |
| Extra Nutrients | Vitamins A, B2, B12, E; minerals (calcium, phosphorus, magnesium); essential fatty acids | 19 types of essential amino acids |
| Type of Collagen | Whole food form with complete nutrient profile | Hydrolysed, broken-down peptides |
| How Well It Absorbs | Natural absorption with complementary nutrients | Better absorption through smaller peptides |
| Main Benefits | – Anti-inflammatory properties – Digestive health support – Sleep promotion through glycine – Weight management | – Increased bone mineral density – Better skin hydration and elasticity – Osteoarthritis relief – Targeted collagen delivery |
| Research Backing | Limited research, mostly theoretical benefits | Extensive clinical trials and decades of research |
| How Long It Lasts | 3 days in refrigerator; 3 months frozen | 1-2 years with proper storage |
| Earth-Friendly Rating | Depends on sourcing and can use food waste | Varies by source; marine collagen is more sustainable |
| Value for Money | Affordable when homemade; pricey for pre-made products | Price changes based on manufacturing location and source type |
Bone broth and collagen supplements each have their own benefits if you want to boost your body’s collagen levels. Research strongly backs collagen supplements, especially when you need specific results like better skin elasticity and stronger bones. Bone broth takes a more natural approach and comes with extra nutrients plus anti-inflammatory benefits, though we need more research to fully understand its effects.
Your age makes a big difference in how much collagen you need. Light supplementation works well if you’re under 30. People over 50 need more collagen, either through concentrated supplements or by drinking bone broth regularly. Your lifestyle, budget, and health goals will help you pick the best option.
Marine collagen supplements are great for eco-conscious people because they have a smaller environmental footprint and use leftover fish parts. Making bone broth at home is budget-friendly, but store-bought premium versions can be expensive. The way you store these products substantially affects how long they last. Collagen supplements can stay good for up to two years with proper handling, while frozen bone broth lasts about three months.
You’ll need to think over your priorities, lifestyle needs, and health goals to choose between bone broth and collagen supplements. Some people get better results by using both, especially those who’ve lost a lot of collagen or want complete nutritional support. Whatever you choose, you’ll get the best results by using it consistently and at the right times.
Q1. Is bone broth or collagen supplement more beneficial for overall health?
Both have unique benefits. Bone broth provides a wider range of nutrients and amino acids, while collagen supplements offer a more concentrated dose of specific collagen types. The choice depends on individual health goals and dietary preferences.
Q2. How much collagen should I consume daily for optimal benefits?
The recommended dosage varies by age. Generally, adults under 50 may benefit from 2.5-5 grammes daily, while those over 50 might need 10-15 grammes. It’s best to consult with a healthcare professional for personalised advice.
Q3. Can I get enough collagen from bone broth alone?
Yes, bone broth can be a sufficient source of collagen. A cup of bone broth typically contains 6-12 grammes of collagen protein. Consuming 175-350ml daily can provide a good amount of collagen along with other beneficial nutrients.
Q4. What’s the best time to consume collagen supplements or bone broth?
For collagen supplements, taking them on an empty stomach can enhance absorption. Bone broth can be beneficial throughout the day, with morning consumption supporting digestive health and evening intake potentially aiding sleep.
Q5. How long do collagen supplements and bone broth last when stored properly?
Collagen supplements typically maintain potency for 1-2 years when stored in a cool, dry place. Homemade bone broth can last up to 3 days in the refrigerator or 3 months when frozen. Always check for signs of spoilage before consumption.
Accepting payments via
YourHealthBasket © 2025
detoxpeople Ltd
Registered in England & Wales 07156741
VAT reg GB 103 3641 60
Our new practitioner portal has been released and it’s now easier than ever to link a client’s account and provide them with suggestions using our new protocol system.
Convert your current cart into a protocol which can then be assigned to a linked client.